The AbyssThe Abyss

Posted on Aug 9th 2008 at 08:10:03 AM by (TraderJake)
Posted under Cynical Gamer, Feature, Nintendo, Sony, Microsoft, Modern Gaming

Imitation is said to be the sincerest form of flattery, well, that’s at least what they say. To me imitation could be a good thing, or, in a market where being unique can lead to being hugely popular and subsequent huge profit margins, a very bad thing. Look for example at Apple. No one is really like Apple in what they do and what they offer. Apple is the trendy tech company, and pending the outcome of a lawsuit, they either will be comfortably the trendy tech company for years to come, or they could see their profit margins erode as the Mac OS is opened up to other hardware manufacturers. Certainly could throw a wrench into things, that’s for sure.

So, what does this talk have to do with gaming? What? Are you serious? Imitation in the gaming realm is making me want to throw up, and I hope you’re as dazed about this imitation as I am.



One has to wonder where the first modern rip offs came into play. Being a young ‘un, I don’t remember the 80s, but I do remember the release of the PlayStation. See, it had a controller, and the original looked like a slightly modified SNES controller. I don’t know if I’d call that a rip off, but of course, the similarity between the original PlayStation controller and the SNES controller are just the tip of a much, much larger imitation Ice Berg.

In the current generation, two things have really screamed “HAHA I AM RIPPING YOU OFF” more than other things… things that just appear out of the blue and seem to be in response to something else. It’s almost as though these companies are afraid not to imitate a gimmick or feature found with another system. You know, it could be for the best.

But no! Here are things that seem like they are reactionary. Sony! What the hell were you thinking with the Sixaxis? Did you really think that tacked on motion control would be the best thing ever for the future of the PlayStation Brand? Perhaps you thought that you could get away with it because only crazy people (or really, really hardcore gamers) would buy a PS3? Whatever it is, it certainly seemed to be reactionary to the Wii Remote. Was it? Who the hell knows, but when you have a controller that looks like a DualShock 2 with motion controls tacked on, one can only speculate that it was.

Microsoft! You don’t appear to be any better! Avatars? Where have I seen those before? Oh that’s right! Miis! Sure, Avatars are more customizable, and if I could create an avatar of Avatar Aang*, that’d just be hilarious. Once again, avatars seem to be reactionary, not just to Nintendo’s Miis, but also the sudden explosion of the casual marketplace. Are they a rip off? Why don’t you decide? I won’t hold your hand.

Nintendo, you too imitate, but you don’t imitate your competitors, instead, this discussion has come full circle. You’re trying so hard to be something that I don’t think you’ll ever be able to be… Apple. Where as Apple has many, many units in addition to computers, Nintendo, you’re just games, and a games company you shall remain. Sure, you make a lot of money being the trendy and chic games company, but at what expense. Did you really think that “core gamers” would find Animal Crossing to be a game for core gamers? No, I don’t think you did, and honestly, I don’t think you cared. You’ve moved beyond core gamers, and before you know it, you might just be the Apple of the gaming world. Congrats. Truly, congrats.

Is it so hard to just be oneself? Some originality goes a long way. But the level of imitation in the games industry is disconcerting, before you know it, companies will be so focused on being reactionary that no one will take risks. I certainly don’t want that. Imitate, but also innovate. Don’t continue this path of reactionary imitation. It’s disgusting.

*I like cartoons. What of it?




Permalink | Comments [3] | Digg This Article |


Recent Entries
In Which I Describe Pizza Tower at an Exhaustingly Long Length (7/31/2024)
Remasters, Remakes, Rereleases, and Remembering the Past (3/30/2024)
The Top 5 Survival Horror Games for the Sega Dreamcast (2/20/2024)
Trombone Champ Is a Good Game (12/30/2023)
Thoughts on the Nintendo Switch OLED Model (11/21/2023)


Comments
 
I agree with you 100%, imitation doesn't do much good, because (usually) the imitation is worse than the original.

The "casual gamer" is another thing that doesn't cease to irritate me. These companies are focussing so hard on getting all the gold out of the casual's pocket they don't know their base anymore. Sure, casual gamers buy hardware but not so much software afterwards.

To me, the Wii is a joke (a succesful joke, but still a joke) with only a handful of "real" good games. But if Microsoft & Sony want to move in that direction aswell, who is going to feed the need of the real gamers out there? Sad
 
*sigh* So true David, so darn true, it makes me cry.... Sad
 
Let me play devil's advocate on this one (everyone picture Homer playing devil's advocate pinball machine).  I design oil & gas processing plants for a living and when doing so I have industry standard safety minimums that must be met.  Now that doesn't always leave a lot of room for creativity, it does help ensure a safe design.

I know safety is not too big of an issue for gaming companies and that we don't want a rigid list of rules that hardware or software must be deisgned too.  But I think as new ideas are introduced and prove to enhance the gaming experience it's fine if they are adapted as standards that we as consumers would expect.

Whether this is true for motion control is probably too early to tell.  I even have friends who refuse to play if they are forced to use the motion controls.  Personally, I'm not too sure the control scheme has added much to my experience on core Nintendo games (mario, zelda) -  and without advancement of their core brands Nintendo doesn't bring much to the table. 

 Login or register to comment
It appears as though you are not a member of our site, or are not logged in.
It appears as though you can not comment currently. Becoming able to comment though is easy! All you need to do is register for the site! Not only will you be able to access any other site features including the forum and collection tools. If you are a registered user and just need to login then you can do so here.

Comment! It's easy, thoughtful, and who knows you might just enjoy it!
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               
This is TraderJake's Blog.
View Profile | RSS
This is where my thoughts go and are never heard from again.

Well, maybe not, but this is the repository for all of my published thoughts and rantings. It'll make my day if you find at least 10% of it amusing and enjoyable to read.


Sorry for the other 90%.

Support the Cincinnati Streetcar
Blog Navigation
Browse Bloggers | My Blog
Hot Entries
Hot Community Entries
Site content Copyright © rfgeneration.com unless otherwise noted. Oh, and keep it on channel three.