Halo is a really good console first person shooter, but that's like being the smartest kid in the retarded class, or the hottest girl in Wal-mart.
This argument of console vs PC FPS's has been going on for a long time. And it seems that there's no "high ground" for the console players to take. So I'll suggest this motto for console FPS fans when dealing with...let's say...PC FPS "snobs": "Don't wrestle with pigs. You get dirty and the pigs enjoy it."
Note: This motto can also apply to dealing with fanboys.