Community Playthrough - Now With Poll - Please Vote

[Fokakis79]

I would definitely play Batman again, I do realize the Wii rarely puts out games Xbox360 and PS3 put out. So there is that problem.

Mass Effect 3 is a good choice, because of its multiple paths, so those that have played it can always play the story a little different.
or we could make it so everyone has to play it through the same way, i.e. Paragon, or Renegade. it is also pretty cheap to pick up, around 17 bucks.

just some thoughts

[Fleach]

Cool idea! That would be a long playthrough so it could get interesting. Your suggestion of a game where player choice influences the experience is a good idea.

 Maybe for something shorter we could do Walking Dead? Just tossing it out there.

[Silent Scythe]

I would do Batman, I've never played and have been wanting to for some time. Mass Effect Sounds good as well but I'd be too tempted to finish the first two first.

All my sources says the US release is 4/16 as well.

[techwizard]

i wouldn't be ok with mass effect 3 because i would most definitely want to play the first 2 first, especially since they have the option of save files connecting over the 3 games.

[Fleach]

I'd have to buy the trilogy edition or whatever it's called. The Mass Effect series has been on my radar for quite some time.

What say you, Crabby? We've got some good proposals here.

[Duke.Togo]

I haven't stopped playing ME3 LOL. I'd be up for going through the trilogy again.

[Crabmaster2000]

I'd have to buy the trilogy edition or whatever it's called. The Mass Effect series has been on my radar for quite some time.

What say you, Crabby? We've got some good proposals here.

Lol, other than Lord of the Rings (I dont know much about them nowadays, but I've been very disappointed with previous LotR games) everything sounds great so far. I've played Mass Effect 1 and 2, but not 3 yet so I'd be very willing to give that a go. And Duke has been bugging me a bit to try The Walking Dead so this would give me yet another reason to pick that one up.

If no one else takes you up on Indigo Prophecy Fleach I might just have to do it with you come October too. I'm really looking forward to Beyond. Maybe we can do like an Indigo Prophecy/Heavy Rain play just before it comes out.

[Crabmaster2000]

Dark/Demon's Souls might be a fun one to do together as a group too. We could help each other past enemies we are having trouble with.

[Barracuda]

Dark/Demon's Souls might be a fun one to do together as a group too. We could help each other past enemies we are having trouble with.

This I would do! It always seems like the games people do these for I never have.

[Fleach]

Never played any of the Mass Effects, so I don't know where I stand on that. Sounds like everyone wants to play the third game.

Dark/Demon Souls is also something I haven't played but I'll vote for one of those.

Honestly, I'm fine with whatever the consensus is. Are there any games with co-op story modes?

[Fokakis79]

I am on NG++ for Demon Souls, and I am a little less than halfway through NG+ on Dark Souls.  So I could be tempted to playthrough, but I am not sure if I am interested in starting all the way over. I could just take my time leveling up and doing other shit, until everyone is about where I am. I would love to help people out on this one, since it can be frustrating at times. I have gotten pretty good at it, and could provide lots of help to those just beginning.  Out of either of these I would choose Dark Souls, to me I had a better experience playing that one.

I am more into Mass Effect 3, since I have not played that one at all, so it would be a fresh run through.


So my vote is Mass Effect 3 first, Dark Souls Second.

Any other suggestions?

This is perfect timing for a playthrough, since I will be done with classes, next week, for a couple of weeks.

[techwizard]

i'm fine with anything really, i'd just rather not jump into a connected story based series like mass effect at the final game...if the consensus is for that i'll probably skip this round . other than that everything else has sounded good so far.

another suggestion is Starcraft Heart of the Swarm, but i know not all of you are PC gamers

[Fleach]

I skimmed through the posts here and we've got these games being mentioned as possible nominees for the next community playthrough:

Pandora's Tower - 4 mentions
Batman: Arkham Asylum - 3 mentions
Indigo Prophecy - 1 mention
Mass Effect 3 - 2 mentions
Dark/Demon Souls - 3 mentions
The Walking Dead - 1 mention

Crabby, can you make a poll so we can cast our votes? Maybe by Monday we'll have a few more suggestions.

[Crabmaster2000]

I skimmed through the posts here and we've got these games being mentioned as possible nominees for the next community playthrough:

Pandora's Tower - 4 mentions
Batman: Arkham Asylum - 3 mentions
Indigo Prophecy - 1 mention
Mass Effect 3 - 2 mentions
Dark/Demon Souls - 3 mentions
The Walking Dead - 1 mention

Crabby, can you make a poll so we can cast our votes? Maybe by Monday we'll have a few more suggestions.

Thanks for gathering those Fleach!! I'll leave it open for a couple more days for suggestions and then I'll add a poll so we can hash out a winner.

[Fleach]

Sounds good. Looking forward to this playthrough.

I like the prospect of a Quantic Dream marathon in the weeks/months leading up to Beyond: Two Souls.

As far as the poll goes, is it possible to cast two votes? Like a primary choice and secondary choice? If not that's ok.