If we are picking 5 I'd probably go with:
Mario Odyssey - Can't wait to be Dinosaur Mario!!
Rabbids X Mario - I had very low expectation on this one going into E3. The combat looks absolutely amazing though and I feel like I might get a few chuckles out of it as well. Definitely looking forward to picking it up!
South Park Fractured But Whole - Been waiting a long long time for this. Absolutely loved the first South Park RPG and this one looks like it's gonna top it in every conceivable way!
Spider-Man - Very excited to have Spider-Man handled by a competent studio. The gameplay demo during Sony's conference made the action look really great (took some serious ques from the Arkham games which I love). Little worried that the story might fall flat after that trailer, but should still be a good time being spidey.
Shadow of the Colossus - Just finished Last Guardian and it's definitely been long enough that I'm ready to dive into this one again. Hoping it's kinda like a director's cut and maybe after you finish the main game they unlock some new Colossus to figure out. That would be epic!
I'm not sure about Beyond Good and Evil. I waited for this game for so long (and I think we'll all be waiting years still), but I just found myself cringing through the entire trailer.
So glad I'm not the only one! I loved Beyond Good and Evil and have been greatly anticipating the sequel. This looked and felt nothing like Beyond Good and Evil though. This article talked about the game behind closed doors and it sounds more like they are going for a Mass Effect style game than a Beyond game. I'm extremely worried its gonna be a huge open world multiplayer game instead of what I want.
http://www.vgchartz.com/a...d-doors-details-revealed/