RF Generation Message Board

Announcements and Feedback => Announcements and Feedback => Topic started by: Addicted on August 15, 2013, 09:42:32 AM



Title: Add EA's Origin as a console platform
Post by: Addicted on August 15, 2013, 09:42:32 AM
Please add Origin as a console platform similar to what was done with Steam. I'm certain I'm not the only one who took advantage of the latest Humble Bundle.


Title: Re: Add EA's Origin as a console platform
Post by: Sirgin on August 15, 2013, 12:47:40 PM
It kind of sucks that other publishers such as EA and Ubisoft want their own Steam-clones. I guess you can't blame them, but it certainly isn't as convenient as having just one DRM login platform.

I have uPlay (Ubisoft's Steam) for a free Splinter Cell game and it's so laughably worse than Steam. All it is is a barebones Steam clone, without many of the nice features that make Steam bearable.


Title: Re: Add EA's Origin as a console platform
Post by: Izret101 on August 18, 2013, 06:25:51 PM
I have games on Steam, Origin, GFWL (no longer supported shortly... FINALLY) and Impulse.
(And Windows 8 Marketplace and of course both WP and WP8 "markets".)

There are way more of these digital distribution platforms than i think most people realize.

EDIT
I have a uPlay account but i don't think i have downloaded any PC games from it. As far as i can remember it has just been their tie in to the 360 retail releases.


Title: Re: Add EA's Origin as a console platform
Post by: Shadow Kisuragi on August 18, 2013, 08:55:43 PM
FWIW, I don't mind adding in these systems. However, we need to be diligent about how we want to track collections for these systems. For instance, Origin doesn't have a Part # that I'm familiar with, unlike Steam's system. If we can accurately document whether or not they're regionwide/regionfree releases, it's not a problem.


Title: Re: Add EA's Origin as a console platform
Post by: Izret101 on August 18, 2013, 09:27:02 PM
Abolish them all until digital only DB is made. (I've been drinking...)


Title: Re: Add EA's Origin as a console platform
Post by: blcklblskt on August 18, 2013, 09:35:25 PM
Abolish them all until digital only DB is made. (I've been drinking...)


Title: Re: Add EA's Origin as a console platform
Post by: Izret101 on August 19, 2013, 10:32:47 AM
Huzzah it still makes sense when sober!

I hate having to scroll through the ever growing list of "systems" in the list of real systems.
Steam is not a system. None of them are systems. They all require a system to play them on.

But the certainly should not be included in standard retail releases as that is outside the original scope of our trackable (physical) collection database. (IMO)



BEAT THAT DEAD HORSE!


Title: Re: Add EA's Origin as a console platform
Post by: douglie007 on October 31, 2013, 02:55:58 PM
why not just make IBM Digital and have Steam, Uplay, Origins and Good Old Games (GOG games) all in one area.  Ironic I just made a post to split a section. 

Huzzah it still makes sense when sober!

I hate having to scroll through the ever growing list of "systems" in the list of real systems.
Steam is not a system. None of them are systems. They all require a system to play them on.

But the certainly should not be included in standard retail releases as that is outside the original scope of our trackable (physical) collection database. (IMO)



BEAT THAT DEAD HORSE!


 I agree the list is getting crazy we could combine like the WiiWare, VC to just Wii Digital and same with other consoles so its not so crowded.


Title: Re: Add EA's Origin as a console platform
Post by: Izret101 on October 31, 2013, 03:07:15 PM
Abolish them all until digital only DB is made. (I've been drinking...)


Title: Re: Add EA's Origin as a console platform
Post by: Tynstar on October 31, 2013, 03:20:25 PM
I have an idea dont track them at all. They are not collectible in any way and this is a collection tool.


Title: Re: Add EA's Origin as a console platform
Post by: blcklblskt on November 01, 2013, 11:05:04 AM
Abolish them all until digital only DB is made. (I've been drinking...)


Title: Re: Add EA's Origin as a console platform
Post by: Link41 on November 01, 2013, 05:51:00 PM
I have an idea dont track them at all. They are not collectible in any way and this is a collection tool.
So by that logic we should go ahead and remove the current digital games database like XBLA and so on? We need to track all or none and just track physical games then. This is going to become more of a serious issue as we move forward in the coming years as more and more digital platforms start to appear. I'm not really sure about mobile. But we should at least look into tracking Downloadable PC games like those of Origin/Steam/Windows 8 etc.


Title: Re: Add EA's Origin as a console platform
Post by: Izret101 on November 01, 2013, 05:52:28 PM


Title: Re: Add EA's Origin as a console platform
Post by: Tynstar on November 04, 2013, 11:21:20 AM
I have an idea dont track them at all. They are not collectible in any way and this is a collection tool.
So by that logic we should go ahead and remove the current digital games database like XBLA and so on?

I agree


Title: Re: Add EA's Origin as a console platform
Post by: Shadow Kisuragi on November 04, 2013, 11:27:23 AM
Sorry to derail the digital train here, but everything has a collectible component - it's just whether or not we want to support tracking it. We are, by site definition, "The classic and modern video games database." Are they not video games?

The site will need to evolve to properly support digital titles. I'm welcome to suggestions, such as splitting them off into their own DB (which I support) which will allow them to have their own details pages to give them proper support. Arranging them in the database is another separate matter.


Title: Re: Add EA's Origin as a console platform
Post by: techwizard on November 04, 2013, 12:08:47 PM
separate database seems to make the most sense to me


Title: Re: Add EA's Origin as a console platform
Post by: Tynstar on November 04, 2013, 03:41:27 PM
Sorry to derail the digital train here, but everything has a collectible component - it's just whether or not we want to support tracking it. We are, by site definition, "The classic and modern video games database." Are they not video games?

The site will need to evolve to properly support digital titles. I'm welcome to suggestions, such as splitting them off into their own DB (which I support) which will allow them to have their own details pages to give them proper support. Arranging them in the database is another separate matter.

Doesnt mean we have to catalog everything.


Title: Re: Add EA's Origin as a console platform
Post by: Izret101 on November 04, 2013, 05:05:46 PM

The site will need to evolve to properly support digital titles. I'm welcome to suggestions, such as splitting them off into their own DB (which I support) which will allow them to have their own details pages to give them proper support. Arranging them in the database is another separate matter.

separate database seems to make the most sense to me


Title: Re: Add EA's Origin as a console platform
Post by: NES_Rules on November 04, 2013, 07:47:58 PM
'm welcome to suggestions, such as splitting them off into their own DB (which I support) which will allow them to have their own details pages to give them proper support. Arranging them in the database is another separate matter.

I think its been pretty damn unanimous that's what we need to do. Actually doing it is the trick. Perfecting the new layout of the pages is the real challenge IMO, they would really only share a similar skeleton to our current game pages, 90% of the page would need to change.